City Clinic Driver to Stand Trial in Market St. Crash that Killed Pedestrian
A San Francisco city employee who struck and killed a woman in a
wheelchair on Market Street nearly two years ago is set to stand trial this
week on a vehicular manslaughter charge.
Antioch resident James Harris was arrested and charged with
misdemeanor vehicular manslaughter following the death of 38-year-old
Berkeley resident Thu Thi Phan on Feb. 5, 2016.
Harris, who was driving a vehicle for the city’s South of Market
Mental Health Services at the time of the collision, struck Phan around 10
a.m. in the crosswalk at Seventh and Market streets.
In an interview with police conducted after the collision, Harris
said that he was in the intersection waiting to make a left turn from
northbound Seventh Street onto Market Street and watching for pedestrians,
but did not see Phan before he struck her on the driver’s side of the
Phan, a U.S. Department of Labor employee who reportedly suffered
from osteogenesis imperfecta, or brittle bone disease, was taken to a
hospital but later died of her injuries.
Harris was turning left from a red lane that is prohibited for
private vehicles. However, left turns are legal at that site for some
vehicles including buses, taxis and city vehicles performing certain
Following the crash, police initially indicated Harris, who
transported clinic clients, might be among those drivers considered exempt
from the restrictions. Charges were later recommended following an
In response to Phan’s death, activists with Walk SF and Senior and
Disability Advocates called for the city to eliminate left turn exemptions
for commercial and city vehicles on Market Street between Third and Eighth
streets, to improve signage clarifying who can legally turn from the red
lanes, and change traffic lights to give pedestrians more of a head start in
crosswalks, among other improvements.
City officials made changes to the signage at the intersection
within a month after Phan’s death.
Phan’s family filed a lawsuit against the city following her
death. A $2.875 million settlement was approved by the Board of Supervisors
on March 17, 2017.
Harris is out of custody on bail. Opening statements in his trial
are expected to start Tuesday.